OBSERVATIONS
September 3, 2020


Wingate Lassiter
THE EDITOR'S POINT OF VIEW

School system's coronavirus reports
are a start, but aren't fully transparent

Here's the announcement we received late last week:

Johnston County Public Schools has begun posting the number of confirmed, school-related COVID-19 cases that are reported to us by the Johnston County Health Department. This will give families and staff more information about how the pandemic is impacting the school system.

Names and other identifying information, including school/site location, will not be released due to privacy laws and the sensitivity of this information.

Superintendent Dr. Eric Bracy said the dashboard is a result of the Board of Education’s intent to be transparent with the community about the pandemic...

But the glaring omission is a breakdown by individual schools showing exactly where COVID-19 outbreaks are taking place.

Other counties are providing that information.

Moore County, for instance --- which re-opened its schools to on-campus learning last week --- is reporting numbers about coronavirus outbreaks at each and every public school within its jurisdiction. (Moore County has 22 public schools, Johnston has 45.)

Those Moore County reports don't identify teachers or students, or even which particular classrooms are affected. But they do share more of "the data" that drives decisions by school leaders about when to allow students on campus and when to keep them all at home till things get better.

Speaking for the public at large, North Carolina's news media by and large have been asking for more COVID-19 data to be shared all along. Reluctantly, it seems, local jurisdictions have been releasing more statistics about what they know as the weeks have gone by.

For instance, in the beginning we weren't getting breakdowns of confirmed cases in each county by ZIP code. Now we see those numbers, updated daily by the state.

Getting the public to cooperate with restrictions put out by the Governor and state health officials to slow down the spread of the virus has been difficult. But if folks had more information about the extent of the pandemic, perhaps they would begin to understand "the science" behind decisions on school and business re-openings and the rules we're being asked to follow.




School board member Peggy Smith voices
frustrations with how remote learning is going


Here's an edited transcript, taken from the school system's website, of her remarks prior to the vote at last week's meeting to delay students' return to campuses:

Before I cast my vote, I have some things to say and some really kind of statements more than questions. There are four former teachers at this table. There are seven parents at this table. So we understand the perspective from all sides.

TEACHERS' CONCERNS

I'm first going to address teacher concerns….

First of all, they're concerned about child care. If they're going to be in the building, we suggest that other employees be assigned to small groups to provide child care for staff children.

The second concern has been inconsistent expectations. Some children are on computers four hours a day, others logging in and out multiple times. There's no consistency and teachers are desperate for some consistent expectations.

The third concern is the schedule. A high-school schedule was developed that we had some objections to, but at least there was a consistent schedule sent out to all the high schools. I have not seen such a schedule for elementary teachers who are desperate to have some consistency. Again, that has been a resounding concern. And we need that schedule pretty quickly, like now.

Number four: multiple log-ins. I understand that we… had a platform that would be a one-stop shop for all places that students had to go and this expectation is not being met. I hear from teachers that their Broadband is not sufficient, that it's kicking people in and out. It's bad.

Number five: Teachers are concerned because staff are not following protocols for masks. As we stated before, this is not an option. We expected everybody to wear masks and that's not happening.

Number six: Working from school was preferred by many, but not if they are being placed at risk. They need to be where their materials are and where their principals can help them but with no masks… people are severely concerned.

Number seven: There aren’t enough teachers. So we suggest, as (board member Ronald) Johnson suggested at the last meeting, that Central Office (staff) and coaches be temporarily assigned to teach until this pandemic is over. It will take everyone working together to survive for the children, and the children are our concern.

Number eight: disruptions. There must be a way for teachers to mute students who talk over them during instruction. Here at Campbell (University, where Dr. Smith is employed), our system allows me to mute everybody as… you ask to speak by raising your hand or chatting. It's a simple fix…. Teachers must have some support for that issue....

PARENTS' CONCERNS


Now I'd like to address, just briefly, parent concerns.

Number one: Not everybody has a hotspot. Parents are being denied because they have Internet, but most parents are at home. Both parents working… and the child cannot access without creating screen and multiple sound problems. We need to accommodate those parents.

Number two: There's no social time for children. We suggest that teachers bring small groups of five to 10 online at a time, varying them so that the whole (group) gets to talk to each other. We also need that social time for children's mental health.They need to see their friends.

Number three: Guidance from the district would set protocols to allow students to talk with each other.

Number four: A hundred or more students online at a time in middle and high school. This is the very antithesis of meeting…. Small groups… with some student talk time is critical to me (for) meeting both academic and social needs…. They're craving being back face to face with their friends. And if that can't happen, that can be face to face virtually.

Many students, as parents, say they are spending too much time on computers. They need some break time.

I also hear that lessons are not able to be accessed. They are live lessons and we need to videotape so that parents can access them when they have to work all day. And most importantly, they need materials. Where are the books that they would have had if they were in the school?...


VIEW the school system's archived video of last Thursday's meeting>




An updated aerial view of SSS & the new parkway

W. Curtis Phillips of the Smithfield-Selma High School Class of 1973 brought to my attention that the aerial photograph of the school's campus published in the Sun two weeks ago wasn't up to date. It showed the realigned driveways but lacked the new blue roofs added more recently. Since the published photo came from the school system's website, I reported his observation to Director of Communication Nathanael Shelton of the Central Office staff and he sent me newer versions taken by drone. Here's one that shows not only the new roofs but also the new Durwood Stephenson Parkway, complete with sidewalks.




Got a comment or a question?

If so, send an e-mail to editor@smithfieldweeklysun.com.
Or, if you prefer, mail a letter to P.O. Box 1363, Smithfield, N.C. 27577.
We'll confirm receipt of your correspondence and, if any or all of it is appropriate for
publication, we'll ask your permission to print before we "go to press." If we publish your submission, all we will show is your name and place of residence. Neither your e-mail address nor your complete postal address will be shared with our readers or anyone else.
To make verification simpler, please sign up as a subscriber if you haven't already done so, using the online form below:

Subscribe to the Smithfield Weekly Sun
(electronic online edition free of charge)

* indicates required

RETURN TO THE SMITHFIELD WEEKLY SUN FRONT PAGE